First Man on Everest- A Controversy - Knowledge Hub

First Man on Everest- A Controversy


mount everest
Yesterday I completed the book Paths of Glory by Jeffrey Archer. To give you an idea of the book I’ll quote from its back cover “Some people have dreams that are so outrageous that if they were to achieve them, their place in history would be guaranteed. Francis Drake, Robert Scott, Percy Fawcett, Charles Lindbergh, Amy Johnson, Sir Edmund Hillary and Neil Armstrong are among such individuals.
But what if one man had such a dream, and when he’d achieved it, there was no proof that he had fulfilled his ambition?
Paths of Glory is the story of such a man. But not until you’ve turned the last page of this extraordinary novel, will you be able to decide if George Mallory should be added to this list of legends, because if he were, another name would have to be removed.”

When I bought the book I thought it to be another fiction from Jeffrey Archer. But the very first page told me that it was based on a true story.
It is the story of George Leigh Mallory, who might be the first man, along with Sandy Irvine, to reach the summit of Mt. Everest, that too in 1924!!

After reading the book I decided to do a research on this- because we all have studied as a student that Sir Edmund Hillary and Sherpa Tenzing Norgay conquered Everest in 1953.

Also read How You Can Receive Birthday Greeting From The Queen – Another post inspired by Jeffrey Archer’s book.

georgemallory
George Mallory was an English man born in 1886. He was a natural climber right from his childhood who climbed everything that was at all possible to climb”. He was the leader of first three British expeditions to climb Mt. Everest.


The first expedition took place in 1921, but was called off after one of the four climbers died of exhaustion and another was sent back due to exhaustion.

The next expedition was sent in 1922 and made to a height of 27,000 feet, higher than anyone had climbed anywhere at that time. They had to head for home due to bad weather which resulted in death of seven Sherpa.

Mallory was reluctant to go for the third expedition, since he had two young daughters, a son and a loving wife back home, but finally agreed to head the expedition. On June 8th 1924 he along with his climbing partner Sandy Irvine was last seen from below by one of the climbing team members, only a few hundred meters from the summit. But they never came back.

Mallory_theory_one_map
It was 75 years later in 1999 that the body of George Mallory was found lying face down, 2, 000 feet below summit.

 
http://www.malloryexpedition.com/george.htm gives some valid reasons to believe that Mallory actually reached the summit:

1) When he started for the expedition he carried a photograph of his wife Ruth to place on the summit. When his body was discovered, the photograph was not found on him, leading experts to believe that he managed to reach the top. (In 1995, George Mallory’s grandson, George Mallory II, reached the summit of Mt. Everest. He then placed a photo of his grandparents at the summit after cutting a hole in the summit.)

2) He was also carrying snow goggles in his pocket which indicates that he had reached the summit and was descending after sunset when the goggles would no longer be required.

3) Various oxygen cylinders were found later near the summit and based on the amount of oxygen left, it can be believed that he reached the summit and was descending.

George Mallory and Sandy Irvine were carrying a camera with them to take photos after reaching the summit. Till date that camera has not been found. If only that camera could be located, the world can come to know whether George Mallory was the first person to reach Mt. Everest.

What are your views regarding this? Do you think George Mallory could have reached the summit?

References:
http://www.everyonehasaneverest.com/george_mallory.asp
http://www.everestnews.com/mallory2005/mallory2005update04112005.htm
http://www.malloryexpedition.com/george.htm
Paths of Glory- Jeffrey Archer

Image Credits:
http://www.everestnews2004.com/malloryandirvine2004/stories2004/pictures/Mallory_theory_one_map.jpg
http://www.lessignets.com/signetsdiane/calendrier/images/mai/1/1/GeorgeMallory1315.jpg

12 Responses to “First Man on Everest- A Controversy”

  1. anurag
    December 30, 2009 at 4:59 pm #

    10x for giving an insight…. I have read the book myself and was really quiet an impressive work of fiction/truth who knows still???

  2. Janardhan Raju
    December 30, 2009 at 5:10 pm #

    Hi I think new site……..

    All the best………

    For free softwares and mobile softwares,games,ebooks….

    Visit my blog

    http://www.123friendz.blogspot.com

  3. Anshul
    December 30, 2009 at 5:35 pm #

    @ Anurag
    You are right..no one knows what the truth is.. but even if George Mallory was the first person to reach the top, Sir Edmund Hillary will be know as the first person to conquer Mt. Everest.. since in the words of Sir Edmund Hillary "If you climb a mountain for the first time and die on the descent, is it really a complete first ascent of the mountain?"

  4. Anshul
    December 30, 2009 at 5:36 pm #

    @ Janardhan Raju
    ya it is a new site.. started last week.. thanks for your wishes :)

  5. DRAVIDIAN
    December 31, 2009 at 11:12 am #

    hi its a nice post.the question still lingers?but i personally believe that Mallory should have definitely made it to the summit.You seem to hav done quite some research before writing this post.
    I had read the book as well and it just consumed me.It was one of the best books of archer.

  6. shashank
    December 31, 2009 at 11:32 am #

    Hi Anshul..
    Well written.
    I havent read it.
    But your post makes it sound really interesting. Will surely read it now.
    Looking to more from you..
    Happy blogging :)

  7. Dan*
    January 4, 2010 at 10:22 pm #

    a little shocked :-D

    nice blog :-)

  8. Anshul
    January 4, 2010 at 11:37 pm #

    @ Dravidian
    its still not clear if Mallory actually was able to reach the top, though i share your opinion :)

  9. Anshul
    January 4, 2010 at 11:38 pm #

    @Shashank
    Thanks Shashank.. will love to hear your views once you have read the book..

  10. Anshul
    January 4, 2010 at 11:40 pm #

    @ Dan
    thx Dan for liking the blog… yeah it is shocking.. if it is proved then a lot many text books will have to be changed :D

  11. ViJ@Y
    June 26, 2010 at 12:08 am #

    hey Anshul, that's really nice post, just thinking of knowing more….Thanks for such post…

  12. free deed search
    November 8, 2010 at 3:21 pm #

    Wow! I am really impressed with your post! That's a good question, whether to believe it or not. I am now excited to purchase a copy of those books you have read because I also love mountain climbing. Until now, I never knew about this trivia or issue.

Leave a Reply

Leave your opinion here. Please be nice. Your Email address will be kept private.